After the four hour trip out to the End of the World, you’ve reached Montauk. The city escape to Montauk can be whatever you make of it: a girls weekend out, a beach resort escape to Gurney’s, or laidback a surfer’s paradise.
The summer can get busy in the Hamptons and it’s best to plan ahead. Prices at hotels are the highest of the year during July and August months. Rentals tend to book up quickly so get ahead of it earlier in the year. Once you’ve secured a place to stay, start making your reservations at some of the best places to eat in Montauk.
There are a lot more options for hotels and lodging in Montauk but for those seeking less of the revelry, the following hotels are great city escapes. From boutique hotels to beach resorts and home rentals, these are some of the best hotels and rentals in Montauk.
What are the best places to stay in Montauk?
GURNEY’S MONTAUK RESORT AND SEAWATER SPA
A major plus of Gurney’s is the private beach access with cabanas, beach chairs/umbrellas, and full food and beverage service right on the beach. You get access to all the great amenities you’d expect from a big hotel from a spa to a gym and a few dining options all on property. Gurney’s is also pet-friendly, welcoming dogs under 40 lbs. It’s a large property and can get quite busy, especially during peak summer season, but Gurney’s is a year-round resort for those looking to book an off-season stay.
MARRAM
Marram is one of the more recent additions to Montauk. They describe themselves as “barefoot luxury” with a natural and desert aesthetic – cedar wood, brunt orange and terracotta accents, and concrete floors. The waterfront property is right on the Atlantic Ocean and features a surf shop for those looking for activity. There are also fire pits to enjoy post beach, a pool right by the ocean, and complimentary cruiser bikes. There are 96 rooms making it more of a boutique hotel feel. There is no sit-down restaurant on property but rather guests can order food from the open air café or venture to top restaurants
MONTAUK BEACH HOUSE
The Montauk Beach House is a block from the beach, located right in the heart of Montauk. A short walk from the beach and from the restaurants and cafes in town, Montauk Beach House is conveniently located. There’s a pool and daybeds for guests to enjoy as well as fire pits on property. The hotel organizes numerous daytime activities such as group fitness sessions and live music. There are only 33 rooms so the property is more intimate.
HERO BEACH CLUB
Hero Beach Club is a 34-room hotel right off Montauk Highway offers ocean views and a coastal, vintage aesthetic. It’s hard to miss the bright, yellow smiley face painted on the white façade of the hotel. Across from Umbrella Beach, the property also has a pool surrounded by cabanas and furniture from Bali as well as an open lawn where they host yoga several times a week. Many of the rooms have a private patio or balcony, perfect to relax after a day of surf and sun. There is no restaurant on property but a light breakfast of coffee and bagels are served during the summer weekends.
What are the best options for rental properties in Montauk?
MCKINLEY BUNGALOW
McKinley Bungalow is the perfect option for design enthusiasts and those looking for a curated at-home vibe when staying in Montauk. It is located in a quiet neighborhood and serves as a change of pace to what can be a lively summer scene at the popular hotels in town. The three bedroom, two bathroom ranch style home is outfitted in curated vintage pieces and objects from Studio Robert McKinley – all of which are for sale. (For those unfamiliar with Robert McKinley, he is the man behind the interiors of Montauk hot spots Surf Lodge and Ruschmeyers.)
DECA MILL OCEANFRONT BUNGALOW
At an average of $2,500/night, this home is perfect for those looking for a chic and elegant Montauk getaway. Sprawled across 3500 square feet, the home boasts 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms and ocean views. The deck and patios of the home are perfect for whale watching in the evenings. The home features warm wooden details throughout, an expansive deck with ocean views and a grill and dining area for the ultimate dinner al fresco. The interior design evokes a California-style beach escape. On property guests will also find surfboards, paddleboards, boogie boards, and kayaks for water activities.
Book the Deca Mill Oceanfront Bungalow
MODERN OCEAN VIEW MONTAUK HOME
The perfect home for a family getaway, this Hither Hills home is a quick walk to the Hither Hills private beach. With the rental, guests will also be given a beach parking pass. The home has 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms, averaging at $1,900 a night. There is a large, heated saltwater gunite pool and a deck with views of the ocean.
Book the Modern Ocean View Montauk Home
CHIC LUXURY MONTAUK CABIN
This newly renovated rental sits on 2 acres in Montauk. A historic fisherman’s cabin that has been renovated in a coastal, clean aesthetic averages at $800/night. The 2 bedroom, 1.5 bathroom cabin is equipped with a chic Lacanche range, brass detailing, a deep hinoki wood Japanese soaking tub, new oak floors, and a stone fireplace. The back deck is the perfect place to lounge with a book or glass of wine and the home is located near restaurants and parks for outdoor activities.
Book the Chic Luxury Montauk Cabin
MODERN MONTAUK HOME
This newly renovated Montauk home is a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom rental minutes from downtown Montauk. The modern farmhouse features a heated gunite pool and wooden beams throughout the home. Averaging around $775 a night, this modern home is a 5 minute drive from Ditch Plains Beach.
LAID-BACK MONTAUK BUNGALOW
A fisherman’s cottage remade into relaxed 2 bedroom bungalow. Conveniently located 5 minutes from the Surf Lodge, this bungalow is west facing across Fort Pond and offers evening sunset views. Outside, you will find a fenced yard with a barbecue area with picnic table and lounge area. The cozy 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom bungalow averages at $320 a night.